Authority Under God. And None as an A-theist.

comment 1
the godless side

A staff member of the church we used to attend, one of the core founders actually, a mom of 3, and a friend of mine just recently found out about our unbelief.  Heartbroken, she wanted to talk over lunch.

I didn’t want to inundate her with all the standard atheist answers, especially because I was such a strong leader in our church and she always used me as an example to her children.  “I’m so grateful that my girls have someone like you to look up to,” she would tell me.  So, I was honest with her about my unbelief but eased into the effects on my life.

For example, she mentioned how scary it must be living day to day without any sort of guide.  I must feel so lost having no anchor from which to guide my life and daily decisions.  What do I do?  How do I form any sort of basis or theme for my life?  If everything is subjective and there is no solid foundation, is that not the scariest thing in the world?

I agreed with her to an extent because I felt relating to her worldview was important in this particular conversation.  But I now feel the need to delve further into this topic, hence this post, so that I can communicate more clearly to her (and others and myself) why I’m not really “lost” and “afraid.”  Or, as another Christian friend recently told me, I am “in free fall, in darkness and confusion.”  Hm.  I disagree.  Let’s explore why.

I don’t need someone telling me what to do.  In fact, having that has crippled me.

For pretty much… actually all… of my life, there has been someone in authority “guiding” me.  My parents, church leaders, the Bible, my pastors, abusive relationships, lifestyle agreements from my university, doctrinal statements from our particular denomination, my signature on such statements when I became employed as a missionary, the country, area, and regional directors over us as missionaries, GOD himself!!! … etc.  I have never, ever had a time in my life where I have been free, myself, completely just me to answer to when it came to making my own life decisions.  How crazy is that???

Every single tiny decision of every single tiny moment of every single day of my life was motivated by an external force.  As well as every single big decision.  Here are just a few:

  • God was the reason I didn’t pursue my interest in brain surgery.  Despite my grades, ACT score, and scientific understanding, I was called to be a missionary not a doctor.
  • God was the reason I made every major move in my life (3000 miles away for college at a Christian University, back home for therapy, to another state for missional work, and overseas as missionaries).
  • God was the reason I ate chocolate sometimes (celebrate the life he gave me) and vegetables other times (be a good steward of the body he gave me).
  • God was the reason I stayed up late talking to friends (I was ministering to them by being an example of Christ to them) and waking up early (to pray, read the Bible, worship).
  • God was the reason I studied hard for tests, and I always asked for his help while I took them.
  • God was the reason I died my hair red for a year (the Holy Spirit set me on fire and set me free).
  •  He was the reason I wore colorful clothing (showing the world the Joy of the Spirit in me).
  • He was the reason I got the job at a cubicle that almost drove me crazy.
  • He was the reason I got the job I did working with homeless people in the inner city
  • He was the reason I married my husband (God told me I would marry the man who proposed the way my husband did.  And I prayed and prayed and PRAYED before I was sure I knew he was the man for me).
  • God was the reason we sold our apartment and lived nomadic lives for the past 2.5 years raising awareness and support for missions.
  • ……. sooooooo many more things

So, now I can finally, FINALLY do what I want.  What I WANT.  For me, just me.  I wrote an earlier blog that touched on this subject, What Would Teal Do.  It speaks more to my feelings on this topic when I first realized this strange freedom.

But having a covering is so necessary. Authority protects you.

This would be the Christian response to what I said above.  I believed this wholeheartedly my whole life.  And you know what?  Authority actually SCREWED me up.  I DID trust them.  But instead, they did everything BUT protect me.  Authority walked all over me and told me to obey anyway.  Authority told me to sacrifice my life, my identity, my sexuality, my everything for the greater freedom.  This has been the case for pretty much all authority that has ever been over me, especially those most recently over us during our missions journey who threw us all over the world (truly), deceived us about what our life would be, and then told us to be good ole Christians, bite the bullet, and be flexible because that’s what God would want.

Does that sound like protection to you???

Honestly guys, I DON’T think authority protects.  I think it can be extremely dangerous, and has been for me over and over and over again in my life.   You want examples?  Just ask.  I’ll go on for days.

Now, there is a place for law and order.  I am protected by murder being illegal, among a thousand other things.  But I don’t not murder because some cop tells me I can’t.  Or because some God tells me I can’t.  I choose not to murder because I, myself, don’t want to.

So, back to the original thought:  Am I really so lost?

I think I was 1000000% more lost believing and following authority so blindly, whatever I placed my authority in, whether it be someone’s interpretation of the Bible or my experiences with God.  I’m now dealing with all this lostness I had before, seeking therapy today for all sorts of problems that were concealed by religion for so long.

So all of those “guiding” moments from theism?  If I’m ever to hope to find real freedom and guidance in this life, keep me as far away from that as possible.

Checkmate. No more a Pawn in this life.

Checkmate. No more a Pawn in this life.

The Author

I'm a closet atheist christian missionary. Paradigm shifts happen frequently for those who allow themselves to think critically about currently held beliefs and openly about new ones. I’ve developed the skill, or perhaps addiction, for change but the community around me is slow to catch up -- and would damn me if they knew where I stood.

1 Comment

  1. Gorf says

    While I don’t share your certainty that God doesn’t exist, it does bug me that people would tell you to do things, “because God wants you to.” Even if God exists, how do *they* know what God wants for *you*? If God exists, and I felt I had experience to help my children who had little experience, I would consider it my duty to teach them so they aren’t completely lost trying to figure it all out on their own. So I see the reason in having preachers, teachers, parents, etc.

    But once people are old enough to make responsible decisions (let’s say at least by age 18, even though the brain isn’t fully developed until around age 25–specifically the pre-frontal cortex, which is implicated in decision-making) we have an obligation to step back and let people exercise their autonomy and judgement, because we recognize our own limitations and misjudgements. Because we know we’re not perfect and don’t necessarily know “God’s will,” even believers should be able to trust others enough to allow them to judge for themselves what “God wants”–not using coercion and someone’s trust in God to get our way. (Or, “what they want,” if neither party believes in God.)

    I do want to distinguish that I do believe there’s a difference between saying, “I think this is the best thing, and this is what I would do,” and “This is what God wants for you.” I believe religious people can share their beliefs without coercion.

    I realize that some might point to my religion and accuse it of using coercion, etc. Like you with your atheistic views, I would hope someone would learn to empathize with and understand my religion before criticizing it. Of course, that is a conversation for another time.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s